Splitsider

Tuesday, April 19th, 2011
NBC
28

Ranked: 20 Years of NBC "Must See" Thursday Night Comedies

NBC's had Thursday night as it's big comedy night for nearly 20 years now, moving from "Must See TV" to "Comedy Night Done Right." Over all that time, they've tossed 38 shows our way, and counting. Some are comedy classics ranking amongst the best sitcoms ever created. Others? Well, let's put it this way: remember Daddio, starring Michael Chiklis? Nobody else does, either. Let's take a look at all of 'em in order from worst to best.

#38. Coupling (2003)
Episodes: 4 (plus 7 unaired)
Quality-wise, there have been worse shows on NBC Thursday nights, which you’ll soon see, but the U.S. remake of Coupling deserves to be last because it managed to tarnish the legacy of BBC’s near-perfect original. The great Steven Moffat helmed both versions, and the U.S. one starred the otherwise-charming Jay Harrington, so NBC's meddling is to blame for this mega-hyped screw-up. Good thing they’d right their wrong with another BBC remake…

#37. Battery Park (2000)
Episodes: 4 (plus 3 unaired)
In 1999, ABC aired the pilot episode of the Charlie Sheen-starring Sugar Hill, a police-themed sitcom. It would be the show’s only episode — until a year later, when NBC re-tooled the sitcom, now called Battery Park. It starred Elizabeth Perkins and Justin Louis and lasted four times as long as Sugar Hill! Meaning, four episodes were shown before NBC said no more.

#36. Daddio (2000)
Episodes: 9 (plus 9 unaired)
I at least vaguely remember, not to mention watched, every sitcom on this list, with the exception of Daddio. It ran for nine episodes and starred a pre-Shield Michael Chiklis as a stay-at-home dad, but nope, nothing. At least the next selection was memorably bad, rather than forgetfully so.

#35. Fired Up (1997-1998)
Episodes: 23 (plus 5 unaired)
The show's tagline: "First she got fired, then she got fired up!" UGH, NEXT.

#34. Inside Schwartz (2001-2002)
Episodes: 9 (plus 4 unaired)
Doing something different isn’t always a good thing for a sitcom. For instance, Inside Schwartz — well, here’s the NBC press release to explain the show, “The series focuses on Schwartz as he struggles to come to terms with both his love of sports — where there are definite rules and official referees — and his personal life, where there are no designated foul lines." That stupid press release talk is sadly accurate, too: the show used sports metaphors to discuss Schwartz’s love life. For instance, when a date licks him on the face, a referee says, “Illegal use of tongue!”

#33. Good Morning, Miami (2002-2003)
Episodes: 40
I mentioned this story elsewhere on the Internet, so Mom, if you’re reading this, I apologize for being repetitive: a screener copy of Good Morning, Miami was sent to my home in early 2002. I was 13 years old at the time, and super excited to receive a VHS copy of a show that hadn’t been on the air yet. A note came with the pilot episode, asking my mom and I to send our thoughts about the show after watching it. Twenty-two minutes later, I put on a pair of boots, ejected the video from the VCR, and literally stomped on it until it was smashed into countless pieces. The show was that bad.

#32. Union Square (1997)
Episodes: 13
Union Square was a sitcom that ripped off characters from other, more popular sitcoms on the same network. Constance Marie played Gabriella Diaz, a lawyer-turned-playwright who befriended people she met in a fictional coffee shop in New York City. It was one of the many failed shows hoping to capitalize on the success of Seinfeld and Friends.

#31. Kath & Kim (2008-2009)
Episodes: 17
While not quite as bad as Coupling, Kath & Kim still suffered from many of the same problems, including the peculiar casting of Molly Shannon and Selma Blair as the titular mother and daughter duo and trying to Americanize the characters while also keeping them consistent to the Australian original. But at least the Scissor Sisters did the theme song! (That’s not a good thing.)

#30. The Single Guy (1995-1997)
Episodes: 44
I'll save you many pointless, Seinfeld-rip off hours of your life: in the final episode, The Single Guy becomes The Married Guy. Believe me, I'm doing you a favor.

#29. Hope & Gloria (1995-1996)
Episodes: 35
There are certain shows that just kind of come and go. They’re not offensively awful or critically loved; they just kind of came and went, no fuss and no uproar. That’s Hope & Gloria in a nutshell, about a producer (Cynthia Stevenson) of a daytime talk show becoming friends with a hairdresser (Jessica Lundy). Alan Thicke is in there, too, but here’s a pop culture tip: unless it’s preceded by “Bob” or “raising,” it’s probably not wise to include “hope” in your title (see: Hope Floats, Hope Springs, etc.).

#28. Leap of Faith (2002)
Episodes: 6
Another show about a group of well-off people hanging out in New York, Leap of Faith averaged 16.5 million viewers per episode in a post-Friends timeslot, but was still canceled after six episodes because no show with the wonderful Ken Marino can last very long. Unlike Veronica Mars and Party Down, though, Leap of Faith deserved to be canned.

#27-25. Jesse/Veronica’s Closet/Caroline in the City (1998-2000, 1997-2000, 1995-1999)
Episodes: 42/66/97
Honestly, all three of these shows blend together. David Crane and Martha Kauffman produced Jesse and Veronica’s Closet, and they’re all about strong, single women trying to make it in a male-dominated world. Another similarity between the three: jokes that wouldn’t have even made it into the first draft of the second Sex and the City movie.

#24. Suddenly Susan (1996-2000)
Episodes: 93
This could have easily been bunched in with the last selection, but at least Suddenly Susan, about the staff of a magazine in San Francisco, had Brooke Shields, who I’ve always liked, Judd Nelson, and Nestor Carbonell. Could have done without Kathy Griffin but that’s not exclusive to Suddenly Susan.

#23. Cursed/The Weber Show (2000-2001)
Episodes: 17
Many critics were calling out for Cougar Town to change its awful title between seasons one and two, an almost unheard of move. But Cursed did something even more shocking: it changed its name mid-way through its freshman year. Originally, Cursed was about Chris Elliot having been, well, cursed by an ex-girlfriend, but because no one was watching, NBC re-titled the show to the more conventional The Weber Show. Didn’t help, and it was axed after less than a full season.

#22. Boston Common (1996-1997)
Episodes: 32
Boston Common tried to do for the Land of Fenway what Friends did for New York City, which is to say only show the nicest parts of it. Obviously, it didn’t succeed, although it did give Zach Galifianakis an early gig.

#21. Four Kings (2006)
Episodes: 7 (plus 6 unaired)
Doesn't Four Kings sound like a USA Network drama? Maybe that's why no one watched the Seth Green-starring sitcom about, you guessed, a group of friends making it in New York City. It was either that, or people were scared off when they heard the Counting Crows' theme song.

#20. Outsourced (2010-Present)
Episodes: 20+
Hey look, a show that isn't about white people! It’s about making fun of people who AREN'T white! What an original idea, NBC. Anisha Nagarajan and Rebecca Hazlewood, the show’s two bright spots, really deserve better. Outsourced's legacy will be that it kept Parks and Recreation off the air for a few months.

#19. Joey (2004-2006)
Episodes: 46
Unless you’re Kelsey Grammar, it has to be tiring, not to mention boring, to play the same character for over a decade. Matt LeBlanc, who played the lovable goofball Joey on Friends, tried taking his talents to California in this spin-off.

Tags:

must see tv, nbc, tv

  • ScoopChang

    Scrubs? Respect? Haaaaaa!

    At least #1 is eternally reliable.

  • Doc

    What about NewsRadio? Was it never on Thursday nights?

    • Joshua Kurp

      @Doc It should have been, but wasn't. Tuesday and Wednesday.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ben-Worcester/818292220 Ben Worcester

      @Doc @Joshua Kurp Were it on Thursdays… NewsRadio would def be Top 5.

  • http://www.seanandmeghan.net sean oconnor

    Maybe a 22 year old shouldn't be ranking the shows of the past 20 years?

    I don't care for Friends or Will & Grace but to have Community, Scrubs, My Name is Earl listed above them is ridiculous.

  • Funny Chris

    No mention of Cheers? A Thursday night staple prior to Seinfeld taking the time slot. Cheers is iconic and I think this list is too heavily focused on modern shows rather than amazing classics. Limiting it to only the past 20 years also cuts out the Cosby Show.

    • Joshua Kurp

      @Funny Chris Cheers is undeniably fantastic, but it wasn't on Thursday nights when NBC introduced the "Must See TV" slogan. Ditto Cosby. Only reason why.

    • Funny Chris
    • Funny Chris

      @Joshua Kurp – the only reason I would challenge that is NBC in 2002 launched a "20 years of Must See TV" advertising blitz of their own highlighting classics like the Cosby Show and Cheers.

    • Joshua Kurp

      @Funny Chris For what it's worth, if Cheers had been on the list, it'd be #3.

    • Funny Chris

      @Joshua Kurp – A fair ranking, except on my list, 30 Rock falls just below "Just Shoot Me". It's too soon to tell, and maybe it'll develop a real audience, but as far as having an impact on television comedies, I think it'll be a show rarely remembered after it is off the air, even though it is rarely remembered while it is currently on the air. That's the problem with making these types of lists though while shows are still on the air. When it comes to their impact on television and television comedy, it's probably too soon to compare a "30 Rock" to "Mad About You" (which was loved while on the air but you correctly note nobody talks about now).

    • grovberg

      @Joshua Kurp According to Wikipedia (I know) "Must See TV" was invented specifically for those two shows. I have no idea if it's true, but I literally just read that yesterday because I've been watching the hell out of Cheers on Netflix over the last week and I've been shocked by how well it holds up.

      Also glad to see Scrubs getting its due. It gets a lot of knocks, but it's first 4-5 season are pretty great.

      Also, can anyone explain to me why Jennifer Aniston is the only one that's naked in that Friends poster?

    • MrG

      @Funny Chris 'Cheers' holds up with the best of them. Outside of some of the fashion decisions, it's pretty much timeless.

  • Megh Wright

    I'm not going to lie, I used to love Will & Grace. I may or may not have had the first season on DVD at one point.

    Also — Josh Kurp. Like…Josh Burp. HA!

  • Bill Haverchuck

    this is certain to be an unpopular opinion, but i enjoyed "kath & kim" a hell of a lot more than pretty much anything below #11 (also: "scrubs & "friends").
    now hear me out: i avoided seeing the much-reviled first 2 or 3 episodes of the series that informed most viewer's opinions of the show, tuned in a few minutes early for "the office" one thursday & caught the last 10 minutes or so of a mid-season episode. there were a handful of things that made me laugh – i know, i was surprised, too! – & nothing that really irritated me so i decided to watch a full episode the next week. and that episode had a pretty decent amount of laughs!
    it's certainly not in the same league as any of the current thursday night line-up (with the exceptions of "paul reiser" & "outsourced", of course), or classics like "seinfeld", "newsradio", "cheers" or "frasier", but it sure wasn't as awful as a lot of people remember it being.

    well, okay, the first 2 or 3 episodes weren't very good at all.

  • JoshUng

    I'll sing on for the "Scrubs deserves more respect" petition. Actually, when they did the "new Scrubs" Bill Lawrence wanted to change the name of the show, and on Twitter he says he never liked "Cougar Town" as a name. So the guy pretty much has made a living off of shows that at one point he wanted to rename.

  • Funny Chris

    I think David Spade had a douchebag character long before Just Shoot Me. On Saturday Night Live he had the "Hollywood Minute" which was all about Douchebaggery, or the "Total Bastard Airlines" sketch, or the "Spade in America" sketch. That is David Spade. I'd say that him playing the strait man to Chris Farley is his acting, and he still plays a pompous Douche Bag there as well.

  • Shannon Garcia

    I swear to God I have never seen or heard of 90% of these shows. Maybe because I'm only 24 and NBC was once overwhemingly white(I'm black-hispanic). They have made great progress in diversifying their characters. Which is why I watch it more.

    Anyway, Will and Grace and Just Shoot were very funny shows. So, I don't agree with you on that. I will also sign the "Scrubs deserves more respect" petition.

  • Kim Schwartz@twitter

    Ummm… I remember a promo for Daddio. It had Chiklis folding laundry while singing a kid's song and then his son walks by singing "Roxanne." wasn't funny then. isn't funny now.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Hall/1605914261 Daniel Hall

    I remember every single one of these shows and the horrible trend of corporatized entertainment by numbers and duplication of successful formulas that most of these shows represent. This just reminded me that what network sit-coms need is another Norman Lear. It's sad that 70's sitcoms were more creatively progressive and funnier than the mostly crap formulaic sit-coms of the modern era.

  • Chris Engelke@facebook

    I gotta say how VERY happy I am that Community is up there. It really is one of my favorite shows that I have seen on any network in a very long time. Am I the only person who thinks Seinfeld is way overrated?

    • steakm

      @Chris Engelke@facebook yes

    • grumblecore

      @Chris Engelke@facebook No. I don't get the Seinfeld hype either, but maybe that's because I'm not white or from a big city? I am a sarcastic asshole though, so it should have some appeal for me. I just can't make myself care.

  • wygby

    Except number 1 the top five don't deserve to be there. NUmber 1 is the greatest show of all time not just NBC Thurdsays. And number 2 should always be Cheers!

  • steakm

    Your number 1 was right… thats about it. You give Community way too much love (and the simpsons is just as influential as seinfeld)

  • dikwad

    It's interesting how poorly a lot of comedy ages. I find Seinfeld unwatchable now, but I watched it every week when it was on. In ten years, I hope I'm not groaning when I see a rerun of 30 Rock or Parks & Rec.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Caroline-Anderson/731041782 Caroline Anderson

    Where does Paul Reiser Show belong?

  • mkmChicago

    ummm, Cosby show ended in 92, Night Court in 94, Different World in 93, Cheers in 93 and every one of them is far superior to everything on this list except Seinfield and Frasier. In fact, the "Must See TV" tagline was created in the mid 80's when the Thursday night juggernaught included Hill Street Blues. The exclusion of the best of what Must See TV offered makes this list a pitiful abombination

-->