Some episodes of SNL are bigger than the host. For example, this season's premiere spotlighted the show's record six new cast members, while host Tina Fey shone in serviceable roles, like her pep talk to Cecily Strong in the latter's first time co-hosting Weekend Update. Similarly, last season's finale focused less on Ben Affleck's career comeback than it did on saying goodbye to Bill Hader and Fred Armisen (and Jason Sudeikis, though his departure hadn't been officially announced at that point). It's an awkward position for the host to find him or herself in, because not only do they feel the pressure to satisfy viewers tuning in to watch them deliver the goods, they also have to dance around some other elephant in the room: favorites leaving, unknowns arriving, diversity controversies, national tragedies, etc.
Melissa McCarthy is an interesting choice to host Seth Meyers' final episode. No host has been as formidable a presence on the SNL stage in the past few years than McCarthy — the actress has been the most electric performer the show has seen since Chris Farley. She doesn't need her hand held… she just walks into a sketch and blows it up. However, on a night when many viewers' minds are wrapped up in Seth Meyers' run on the show coming to a end, it's a little difficult to get on board with a Melissa McCarthy Variety Hour, as hilarious as it may be.
It's not as though McCarthy's performance was any less explosive than usual. She worked her ass off — flipping around on high wires, crashing through windows, smearing her face with barbecue sauce, even letting out SNL's first expletive since the Jenny Slate F-bomb in 2009. However, the Groundlings alum is at her core a live performer who feeds off the energy from the studio audience, and from those of watching at home, the crowd seemed a little lukewarm. Of course, you should never blame the house (unless it's filled with 14-year-old girls who scream at everything Justin Bieber says, in which case, yes, you should), but it's fair to question the selection of a host known for being the most memorable thing about an episode on a night we want to remember for something else. If recent Golden Globe winners Amy Poehler and Andy Samberg are available for a cameo, it begs to reason that the show could have celebrated Seth Meyers' swan song by booking an alum he has more of a history with, and saved ace-in-the-hole Melissa McCarthy for a week when Meyers is gone, when SNL will need her the most.
But it's not fair to nitpick with hypothetical alternatives, especially when the show hasn't even booked a host for its next episode on March 1. At the end of the day, this was another delightful, well-written episode, with a nearly flawless first half, a few nice pieces to close things out, some unforgettable moments from a golden Melissa McCarthy, and a fitting farewell for Seth Meyers. READ MORE